1989 SCMR 2022 SUPREME-COURT

Full text

TARIQ BUTT VS JAVAID PAUL Constitution of Pakistan 1973--185 , Establishment Manual Vol. I--TERM , West Pakistan Urban Rent Restriction Ordinance 1959--13 , ---S.13--Constitution of Pakistan (1973), Art. 185 (3)--Landlord and tenant-Tenant's plea of absence of the relationship of landlord and tenant was rejected throughout--Tenant himself having executed a rent note in favour of landlord could not subsequently deny relationship of landlord and tenant--Tenant's plea that rent note was executed on 11-7-1985 while reg1stered sale-deed in landlord's favour was executed on 14-7-1985, would not make any difference because sale deed was prepared and executed on 10-7-1985 but was reg1stered four days later-Rent note by tenant in favour of landlord was thus neither improper nor illegal-Tenant, after executing rent note in landlord's favour, could not successfully deny relationship of landlord and tenant between himself and the acknowledged landlord--Tenant's further plea that landlord having himself asserted that tenant had sent the rent after execution of reg1stered sale-deed, his eviction application should have been dismissed in exercise of discretion, would be of no a